Psjunkie wrote:I appreciate your taking time Duck, I feel your crop has validity but am a bit partial to the darker reflections.....Your suggestions caused discussion and discussion is always a good thing...
As I mentioned earlier, the critique I made was based on viewing your image and imagining
how I may tweak it. That doesn't mean the reality will completely match expectations. In this case, it didn't. I agree that the darker reflection draws better attention into the scene but I went forward with my original line of thought as an exercise in experimentation, if for nothing else.
The crop was definitely done to show how a simple omission can change the narrative of a story. That, in itself, is worthy of a lengthy discussion. Hmm... maybe the start of a new thread?
Anyway, I appreciate you indulging an alternative view.