Page 2 of 2

Re: The Beauty of Ugliness

Posted: Tue Oct 24, 2017 12:09 am
by minniev
LindaShorey wrote:Masterful work, Minnie. One of those that causes me to wonder if I'd have seen the potential. I fear not, which makes this a great image for inspiration/teaching: a reminder to think outside that pesky little box we get ourselves into on occasion.


We all have moments when we spot something unusual and find a way to make an image of it. I think those are the ones I enjoy the most, more than the iconic landmarks, the stuff that I know is not photo fodder but somehow I was able to make a pleasing image of it.

Re: The Beauty of Ugliness

Posted: Tue Oct 24, 2017 1:33 am
by LindaShorey
minniev wrote:
We all have moments when we spot something unusual and find a way to make an image of it. I think those are the ones I enjoy the most, more than the iconic landmarks, the stuff that I know is not photo fodder but somehow I was able to make a pleasing image of it.


I am so with you! I have done very little traveling in recent years, but admit the low hanging fruit of Mt Rainier's breathtaking majesty isn't as photographically satisfying as my "red sticks in the snow" or the one posted in pM called "Tension" (grass seed head lying on top of water).

Re: The Beauty of Ugliness

Posted: Tue Oct 24, 2017 1:23 pm
by Graham Smith
I do like industrial stuff and I love this one. I just feel that it is a little too smooth, it needs a touch of harshness to it. It has slipped a bit too much towards soft pastoral landscape.

Re: The Beauty of Ugliness

Posted: Tue Oct 24, 2017 2:11 pm
by davechinn
minniev wrote:Not a city skyline for sure and not sure about the architecture but it sure ain't scenic or landscape. I have a secret vice of photographing what I call "industrials", working or failed industrial sites. I hate their pollution, the scars they put on the landscape, but I still feel compelled to photograph them. Here's one I found in Quebec. All critique, edits, suggestions welcome. Sometimes I process them harshly to emphasize the ugliness, sometimes creatively/artistically to make them seem prettier, sometimes mostly realistically to let them speak for themselves.


The title speaks for itself, no other words are needed for a description with this one Minnie !!! A fine capture along with post processing to get your point across.
Dave

Re: The Beauty of Ugliness

Posted: Wed Oct 25, 2017 3:19 am
by Matt Quinn
minniev wrote:Not a city skyline for sure and not sure about the architecture but it sure ain't scenic or landscape. I have a secret vice of photographing what I call "industrials", working or failed industrial sites. I hate their pollution, the scars they put on the landscape, but I still feel compelled to photograph them. Here's one I found in Quebec. All critique, edits, suggestions welcome. Sometimes I process them harshly to emphasize the ugliness, sometimes creatively/artistically to make them seem prettier, sometimes mostly realistically to let them speak for themselves.


Well framed and exposed, Minnie. Very pleasing dof. Tones are rich. Love the pyramids of devastation. I especially enjoy the contrast between the grand fall colors (colours, since this was up north?) in the trees and the raw mounds and raped earth. You have made a very clear and forceful statement. Matt

Re: The Beauty of Ugliness

Posted: Wed Oct 25, 2017 1:25 pm
by minniev
Graham Smith wrote:I do like industrial stuff and I love this one. I just feel that it is a little too smooth, it needs a touch of harshness to it. It has slipped a bit too much towards soft pastoral landscape.


Glad you liked it, it isn't my usual! Thanks for the idea Graham. My notion was to let any viewer see what they wanted: beauty, blight, or both. So perhaps a bit of harshness in the "blight" parts may help that happen?

Re: The Beauty of Ugliness

Posted: Wed Oct 25, 2017 1:26 pm
by minniev
davechinn wrote:
minniev wrote:Not a city skyline for sure and not sure about the architecture but it sure ain't scenic or landscape. I have a secret vice of photographing what I call "industrials", working or failed industrial sites. I hate their pollution, the scars they put on the landscape, but I still feel compelled to photograph them. Here's one I found in Quebec. All critique, edits, suggestions welcome. Sometimes I process them harshly to emphasize the ugliness, sometimes creatively/artistically to make them seem prettier, sometimes mostly realistically to let them speak for themselves.


The title speaks for itself, no other words are needed for a description with this one Minnie !!! A fine capture along with post processing to get your point across.
Dave


Thank you Dave. Sometimes a title comes to me right away and sometimes I search for one and never find it...

Re: The Beauty of Ugliness

Posted: Wed Oct 25, 2017 1:28 pm
by minniev
Matt Quinn wrote:
minniev wrote:Not a city skyline for sure and not sure about the architecture but it sure ain't scenic or landscape. I have a secret vice of photographing what I call "industrials", working or failed industrial sites. I hate their pollution, the scars they put on the landscape, but I still feel compelled to photograph them. Here's one I found in Quebec. All critique, edits, suggestions welcome. Sometimes I process them harshly to emphasize the ugliness, sometimes creatively/artistically to make them seem prettier, sometimes mostly realistically to let them speak for themselves.


Well framed and exposed, Minnie. Very pleasing dof. Tones are rich. Love the pyramids of devastation. I especially enjoy the contrast between the grand fall colors (colours, since this was up north?) in the trees and the raw mounds and raped earth. You have made a very clear and forceful statement. Matt


Glad you found a story in it Matt, my intention was to leave it ambiguous and let anyone looking find their own. That is part of what's interesting about contradictory images of industrials, and probably why I enjoy them. Thanks for your comments.

Re: The Beauty of Ugliness

Posted: Thu Oct 26, 2017 4:10 am
by St3v3M
My immediate thought was Beauty And The Beast, but I think your title is well suited and should be placed on the little placard when you display this.

I hate to say this, but the image would not have been as strong without the air pollution. I hope you have more of these! S-